WordPress or Shopify: how to choose for your store
For most online stores, Shopify is the better choice. WordPress with WooCommerce is the better choice when the site is as much content as catalogue, when you need control that Shopify will not give you, or when the business already runs on WordPress. A small number of stores need neither and should be built custom.
We build and maintain stores on both platforms, so we have no reason to prefer one. What follows is how we decide for a client, and what each choice costs once the store is live, which is where most comparisons stop being useful.
The difference in one paragraph
Shopify is a hosted service. You rent the platform, and Shopify runs the servers, the checkout, the security and the updates. WooCommerce is a free plugin that turns a WordPress site into a store. You own and host everything, which means you control everything and you are responsible for everything. Almost every other difference follows from that.
When Shopify is the right answer
You want to sell, not run software. Hosting, payment security, platform updates and checkout performance are Shopify’s problem. For a team without a developer on staff, that is worth more than any feature.
The checkout matters more than anything else. Shopify’s checkout is fast, trusted by shoppers and kept current without effort on your side. Matching it on WooCommerce takes deliberate work.
You sell across channels. Social shops, marketplaces, in-person sales and newer channels such as AI shopping assistants plug into Shopify with little effort.
Traffic is spiky. Campaigns, drops and seasonal peaks do not need capacity planning, because the platform absorbs them.
When WooCommerce is the right answer
The site is mostly content. Publishers, membership sites, education businesses and brands whose store is one part of a larger site. WordPress is a far better content system than Shopify, and running both side by side is usually worse than one well-built WordPress site.
You need control the platform will not give you. Unusual product logic, custom checkout steps, complex B2B rules, deep integration with systems the business already runs. On Shopify, checkout customisation is limited on every plan below Plus. On WooCommerce, everything is code you own.
You already run on WordPress. If the team knows the admin, the content lives there and the site ranks, adding a store is cheaper and less risky than moving.
You want no platform in the middle. Your data, your hosting, your choice of payment provider, with no platform fee on top of what the payment provider charges.
What each one costs to run
The licence price is the smallest part of the comparison, and the part most articles focus on.
Shopify charges a monthly subscription, from a few dozen a month on Basic to a few hundred on Advanced and thousands on Plus, depending on your region and billing period. If you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments, it also takes a percentage of each sale: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus, according to Shopify’s pricing page as of November 2026. On top of that come paid apps. Apps are how most Shopify stores get the features they need, and a mature store often pays more for apps each month than for the plan itself.
WooCommerce costs nothing to install. You pay for hosting good enough for a store, paid extensions for features such as subscriptions or bookings, and, above all, the time to keep it healthy. WordPress core, WooCommerce, the theme and every plugin update constantly, and a store with an untested update is a store that can stop taking orders. That maintenance is real money every month, and it is the cost people forget when they call WooCommerce free.
The practical comparison: on Shopify the platform and apps cost more, and the upkeep is mostly handled for you. On WooCommerce the software costs less, and the upkeep is your responsibility. Compare the totals over two or three years, not the starting prices.
The questions that decide it
When a client asks us which platform to use, these are the questions we ask, in order.
- Is the site mainly a store, or mainly content with a store attached?
- Does anyone on your team want to manage hosting, updates and security, or pay someone to?
- Is there anything about how you sell that a standard checkout cannot do: configured products, account-specific pricing, approval flows, unusual payment terms?
- Which systems does the store need to talk to: ERP, inventory, fulfilment, accounting? Both platforms integrate, but the effort and the ongoing cost differ.
- Are you already on one of them, and does the current site rank in search?
If the answers are “mainly a store”, “no”, “no”, “the usual” and “no”, it is Shopify, and the conversation is short. Every “yes” moves it towards WooCommerce or, past a certain point, a custom storefront.
When neither fits
Some stores outgrow both: product configurators with thousands of valid combinations, pricing that depends on contracts rather than catalogues, or ordering that is really a B2B workflow with a shop window. These are built as products rather than stores, often with a platform still handling payments or the catalogue behind the scenes. They cost more and they are the right answer less often than agencies suggest.
The mistakes we see
Choosing on the subscription price. A store that saves on the plan and then spends far more on developer time fighting the platform has not saved anything.
Too many plugins or apps. Both platforms make it easy to add one more. Thirty plugins on a WooCommerce store, or fifteen apps on Shopify, means slow pages, conflicts and a monthly bill nobody has added up.
Moving platforms without a redirect plan. Switching between WordPress and Shopify changes almost every URL on the site. Without a mapped redirect for each product and category page, years of search rankings disappear in a week. The migration is the easy half.
Nobody owning the upkeep. This hits WooCommerce hardest, but Shopify stores accumulate app conflicts and theme debt too. A store is a system that changes underneath you every month.
If you are choosing now
Send us what you sell and how you sell it. We will tell you which platform we would use and why, before any build is scoped. If you already have a store that is struggling, we will also tell you whether the platform is the problem, which it often is not.
Related reading
- Ecommerce Development — Shopify, WooCommerce and custom storefronts
- WordPress Development — when the store sits inside a content site
- Website Maintenance — keeping a live store healthy